If you’re out of Old El Paso enchilada sauce or simply want to try a different flavor, this list covers the best substitutes for canned enchilada sauce. Whether you’re cooking for a quick weeknight meal or experimenting with homemade Mexican dishes, these alternatives offer a range of flavors and textures that stand in well for the original. From store-bought sauces to DIY mixes, each option is practical and flavorful.
1. Homemade Enchilada Sauce from Chili Powder and Tomato Sauce
Mixing chili powder, tomato sauce, garlic powder, onion powder, cumin, and a bit of broth can create a quick, fresh enchilada sauce. This substitute allows you to control the heat and seasoning levels, making it a great choice for those who want a tailored flavor. It’s simple to whip up with pantry staples and mimics the classic Old El Paso taste effectively.
2. La Victoria Enchilada Sauce
La Victoria enchilada sauce is a popular canned alternative with a similar texture and a slightly tangier, spicier profile than Old El Paso. It’s widely available in supermarkets and offers a robust flavor that works well for enchiladas, burritos, and Mexican casseroles. This brand is a reliable swap if you want a ready-made sauce with a bit more kick.
3. Herdez Salsa Verde
For a green enchilada sauce substitute, Herdez Salsa Verde is a fantastic option made from tomatillos, green chilies, and spices. While it differs in color and flavor from the traditional red sauce, it adds a fresh, tangy twist that complements chicken and cheese enchiladas beautifully. It’s also widely accessible and requires no additional seasoning.
4. Trader Joe’s Enchilada Sauce
Trader Joe’s enchilada sauce offers a rich, smoky flavor with a balance of mild heat and savory depth. It’s a great substitute for Old El Paso’s sauce because it uses natural ingredients and has a thicker consistency, which helps it cling well to enchiladas. This option is ideal for shoppers seeking a slightly more artisanal or organic product.
5. McCormick Enchilada Sauce Mix
If you prefer making your own sauce from scratch but want convenience, McCormick’s enchilada sauce mix is a go-to. It comes as a dry seasoning blend that you combine with water or tomato sauce to create a fresh sauce. This option lets you adjust thickness and spice levels, perfect for cooks who like flexibility without starting entirely from raw ingredients.
6. Roasted Red Pepper Sauce
Roasted red pepper sauce can serve as an unconventional but tasty substitute for enchilada sauce. While not traditional, its smoky sweetness and vibrant color add complexity to enchiladas. Use it as a base and add chili powder or cumin to approximate the flavor profile of Old El Paso’s sauce.
7. Salsa Roja
Salsa Roja, a cooked red salsa made with tomatoes, onions, garlic, and chilies, is a thinner but flavorful alternative. It brings bright acidity and a fresh tomato taste to dishes and works well when thickened slightly with tomato paste or reduced on the stove. This option is great for those wanting a fresher, less processed flavor than canned sauces.
8. Enchilada Sauce from Chili Paste and Broth
Combining chili paste (such as chipotle or ancho) with chicken or vegetable broth and tomato paste creates a rich, smoky enchilada sauce substitute. This method allows precise control over heat and consistency, making it ideal for cooks who want a bold sauce with a homemade touch. It’s especially good if you have chili pastes on hand.
9. Penzeys Chili Seasoning with Tomato Sauce
Penzeys chili seasoning blend mixed into tomato sauce or broth can replicate the flavor of enchilada sauce well. The blend typically includes cumin, paprika, garlic, and oregano, which are core spices in enchilada sauce. This option is excellent for those who want to customize spice levels and avoid preservatives commonly found in canned sauces.
10. Hatch Green Chile Enchilada Sauce
Hatch green chile enchilada sauce offers a regional twist with its signature mild heat and smoky flavor from New Mexico green chiles. It’s a great alternative for those looking to experiment with different chili profiles while maintaining the saucy consistency needed for enchiladas. This sauce is often available canned or jarred and adds a unique Southwestern flair.
How to Choose
When selecting an Old El Paso enchilada sauce substitute, consider flavor profile, heat level, and availability. If you want something close in taste and texture, canned sauces like La Victoria or Trader Joe’s are ideal. For more control over spice and freshness, homemade mixes or chili paste blends work better. Also, think about whether you prefer red or green sauce styles, as this greatly influences the final dish’s character. Lastly, check ingredient labels if dietary restrictions or preservatives are a concern.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use salsa as a substitute for enchilada sauce?
Yes, salsa roja or salsa verde can be used, but they are usually thinner and less rich than enchilada sauce. Adjust by reducing or thickening the salsa before use.
Is enchilada sauce the same as taco sauce?
No, enchilada sauce tends to be thicker and richer with a deeper chili flavor, while taco sauce is usually thinner and milder.
Can I make enchilada sauce without chili powder?
Chili powder is key for authentic flavor, but you can substitute with ground ancho or chipotle peppers plus cumin and paprika for a similar taste.
How long does homemade enchilada sauce last?
Stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator, homemade sauce typically lasts up to 5 days. Always reheat to at least 165°F before serving.
Can I freeze enchilada sauce?
Yes, both homemade and store-bought enchilada sauces freeze well for up to 3 months. Thaw in the fridge overnight and stir before using.
What can I use if I’m allergic to tomatoes?
Consider using a roasted red pepper sauce or a chili paste and broth mix without tomato base. These can mimic the flavor without tomato ingredients.
Final Thoughts
Finding the right Old El Paso enchilada sauce substitute depends on your taste preferences, ingredient availability, and how much time you want to spend in the kitchen. From convenient canned options like La Victoria to customizable homemade mixes using chili powders and broths, there’s a substitute for every cooking style. Experiment with these alternatives to discover new flavors and keep your enchilada dishes delicious and satisfying, even without the original canned sauce.
Related
- Top 10 Mail Order Seed Sources with Best Germination Rates
- Common Problems Using Antifungal Herbs You Should Know
- Substitutes for Antifungal Herbs in Natural Remedies